Skip to main content

Documentation Index

Fetch the complete documentation index at: https://docs.litigationlabs.io/llms.txt

Use this file to discover all available pages before exploring further.

​
Your First Examination

This guide walks you through conducting your first witness examination in CaseSim, from preparation through completion. By following these steps, you will develop the foundational skills for effective courtroom advocacy.

​
Before You Begin

​
Choose an Appropriate Scenario

For your first examination, select a beginner-level scenario:
  • One or two witnesses
  • Clear, straightforward facts
  • Limited objection challenges
  • Cooperative witness demeanor
Look for scenarios tagged “Beginner” or “Introduction” in the scenario panel. These are designed for new users learning the platform.

​
Understand Your Objective

Your goal is to extract elicits—key facts that support your case theory. Before examining:
  1. Review the witness profile
  2. Identify the elicits assigned to this witness
  3. Note any hints about how to approach each fact
  4. Plan a general question sequence

​
Review the Case Background

Read the scenario description:
  • What is the underlying dispute?
  • Who are the parties?
  • What does each side claim?
  • Where does this witness fit?

​
Starting the Session

​
Session Setup

1

Select the Scenario

Click on your chosen beginner scenario from the scenario panel.
2

Review Details

Read the case background and witness summaries in the detail view.
3

Choose Your Side

Select whether to represent the plaintiff or defendant. For your first examination, choose the side with the most witnesses—you’ll get more direct examination practice.
4

Select a Folder

Choose where to save this session, or use the default location.
5

Begin Session

Click “Start Session” to enter the courtroom.

​
The Opening

When the session starts:
  • The judge delivers opening instructions
  • The first witness is called to the stand
  • You see the witness information in the toolbar
  • The input field becomes active for your first question

​
Your First Questions

​
Establishing the Witness

Begin with identification and background: 
"Please state your name for the record."
Wait for the response, then continue: 
"What is your occupation?"
"How long have you held that position?"
"Are you familiar with the matter we're here to discuss today?"
Why this matters: These questions establish who the witness is and why their testimony is relevant. They also let you observe how the witness responds before asking harder questions.

​
Building to Key Testimony

After establishing the witness, move toward substantive facts: 
"Directing your attention to [relevant date], where were you?"
"What were you doing at that time?"
"Who else was present?"
"What happened?"
Why this matters: These questions set the scene and establish context. You’re building foundation for the key facts you need to elicit.

​
Extracting Key Facts

When you reach a topic where an elicit exists: 
"What was discussed during that meeting?"
"What specifically did [person] say about [topic]?"
"When did that occur?"
"How did you learn about that?"
Why this matters: These questions directly seek the facts you need. Watch for the score popup that indicates when you’ve successfully established an elicit.

​
Handling Responses

​
When the Witness Cooperates

If the answer provides the information you need:
  • Note the score popup if an elicit was established
  • Move to the next topic
  • Build on the testimony with follow-up questions if helpful

​
When the Answer Is Incomplete

If the witness doesn’t provide enough detail: 
"Can you tell me more about that?"
"What exactly did you observe?"
"Please explain what you mean by [vague term]."

​
When the Witness Evades

If the witness avoids answering directly: 
"Let me ask more specifically: [narrower question]"
"I understand, but my question was about [specific topic]."
"Did you or did you not [specific fact]?"
Avoid becoming argumentative. If a witness consistently evades, rephrase your question and try a different approach rather than repeating the same question.

​
Handling Your First Objection

​
When OCA Objects

During your examination, opposing counsel may object:
  1. Stop and read the objection — Note the grounds cited
  2. Evaluate the objection — Is it valid?
  3. Decide your response:
    • If valid: “I’ll rephrase, Your Honor”
    • If invalid: Argue your position
  4. Wait for the ruling — The judge will rule

​
Common First-Time Objections

ObjectionWhat It MeansHow to Respond
”Leading”Your question suggested the answerRephrase as open question: “What happened?” not “Did X happen?"
"Foundation”You haven’t established the basisBack up and establish context first
”Hearsay”You asked about out-of-court statementsLimit to what witness directly observed

​
After the Ruling

  • If sustained: Rephrase and continue
  • If overruled: The witness should answer; proceed
Don’t dwell on objections. Adapt and move forward.

​
Tracking Your Progress

​
The Witness Toolbar

Throughout examination, monitor:
  • Progress bar: Shows percentage of elicits established
  • Elicit list: Individual facts with status
  • Witness health: Credibility indicator

​
Score Popups

When you establish an elicit:
  • A popup confirms the fact
  • Points are added to your score
  • The elicit badge updates

​
When to Move On

Consider moving to the next topic when:
  • You’ve established the elicit
  • The witness clearly cannot provide more
  • Further questions would be repetitive

​
Concluding the Examination

​
Finishing with a Witness

When you’ve covered your planned topics: 
"I have no further questions for this witness, Your Honor."
Or simply click “Proceed” to advance.

​
Phase Transitions

After direct examination:
  • OCA may conduct cross-examination
  • You may have opportunity for redirect
  • The next witness may be called
Follow the prompts to navigate through phases.

​
Ending the Session

When you’ve examined all witnesses or want to stop:
  • Click “End Session”
  • Review your score summary
  • Examine the transcript

​
Review and Learn

​
Immediate Review

After your first session:
  1. Check your score — How did you do?
  2. Review missed elicits — What facts did you not establish?
  3. Read the transcript — What questions worked? What didn’t?

​
Questions to Ask Yourself

  • Did I establish foundation before seeking key facts?
  • Were my questions open-ended on direct?
  • How did I handle objections?
  • What would I do differently?

​
Planning Your Next Session

Based on your review:
  • Retry the same scenario to improve your score
  • Try a different side to practice cross-examination
  • Move to the next scenario to build skills

​
Common First-Time Mistakes

​
Asking Leading Questions on Direct

Mistake: “The meeting was on January 15th, correct?” Better: “When was the meeting?”

​
Skipping Foundation

Mistake: Asking about a document without establishing the witness knows it Better: “Are you familiar with this document?” → “How do you recognize it?” → “What does it show?”

​
Ignoring Objections

Mistake: Continuing to ask the same type of question after it was objected to Better: Learn from the objection and adjust your approach

​
Giving Up Too Quickly

Mistake: Moving on after one vague answer Better: Follow up with more specific questions to get the detail you need

​
Your Development Path

After your first examination:
1

Retry for Improvement

Practice the same scenario again, applying lessons learned.
2

Try Both Sides

Examine from the opposite party’s perspective.
3

Increase Difficulty

Move to intermediate scenarios with more witnesses.
4

Focus on Weaknesses

Target specific skills that need development.
5

Track Progress

Monitor your scores and improvement over time.
Congratulations on completing your first examination. Each session builds skills that transfer to real courtroom practice.